The blog & portfolio of Matthew J. Rogers

Battlestar returns

January 17, 2009

earth8

On Friday, January 16, the first of the final ten episodes of BattleStar Galactica aired on SciFi. As some of you may know, this is one of my favorite shows of all time. Considering the cliffhanger that the last episode left us on back in June of 2008, and how SciFi feels the need to split these “mid-season breaks” into huge 6-month gaps, the anticipation was high. This is going to just be some quick impressions, not a detailed review.

Overall, I thought the episode was very good. Yes, we find out what’s up with Earth and why it’s so desolate (not a huge mystery), as well as who used to be there (that was more surprising). There were lots of new twists in this episode, good ones I think, that will be explored through the final nine shows I’m sure. Edward James Olmos and Mary McDonnell are amazing dramatic actors, and they really carry the emotional weight of this show. The Adama/Roslyn scenes were always so powerful. In contrast, the scenes with Lee and Dualla, in which they’re rediscovering their romantic attraction to each other, were less enjoyable. They felt forced and campy. I never liked that matchup.

Although the mix-in of the newly discovered cylon allies with the regular colonial crew — and the members of the crew who were just outed as cylons — provided a different and quirky “elephant in the room” kind of atmosphere, this show did in some ways represent a return to roots for several characters. Baltar was being a scientist again — no more creepy followers and weird religious rants. Laura was being herself — a strong presence around others yet emotional and fragile in private. Even Tigh seemed to have gotten over the fact that he’s a cylon and tried to be his old self again — his old self when he wasn’t drunk, that is. In that respect, one of the most powerful scenes was when Adama was the raging drunk and Tigh had to talk him down. For all the times that Adama was there for Tigh, now the roles became reversed. It was a very interesting reflection.

Among the many new pieces of information and surprising twists and turns, the most shocking was the sudden — and graphic — loss of a major character that has been with the show from the very beginning. We don’t even yet know why this character died.

Most important of all: we now know who the 5th cylon is.

Battlestar remains excellent television and, I think, one of the best stories ever told on the small screen. If you haven’t watched it and you like human drama, give it a shot. Start with the 2003 miniseries, then move to season one and watch it in order. The DVDs can be had from Netflix or any other video rental store.

2 comments

  • [...] rest is here:  Battlestar returns Related Stuff: Battlestar Galactica 1980 – Complete Battlestar Galactica: Season 4 This entry [...]

  • The Adama/Rosyln relationship is – for a TV Show – amazingly deep and for me one of the reasons I keep watching BSG. It will be really interesting to watch the characters handle the tension that the discovery of a devastated earth brought in. Does Laura give up or does she pull herself together? Will Bill let her slip away, now that they both finally admitted their love?
    Like you pointed out: the series returns to some of its roots. It’s a bold move by the authors, but it’s a necessary one. Just as necessary as the revealing of the 5th cylon. I’m really glad the way it turned out – this way the remaining episodes can concentrate on what made the series strong: all of the main characters, and not just on a single one.

    I’m already counting the hours for the next episode.

Leave a comment