Gadget gift guide 2008: my picks
December 5, 2008
I’m going to take a little intermission before Part 3 of the Navigating the Financiapocalypse series, since I need a little more time to get my thoughts down on investment advice. Instead of saving money, today we’re going to talk about what you should buy if you want to spend some money: gadgets! That’s right, get out there and stimulate our crappy economy any way you can. And yes, you’ll stimulate my personal economy if you buy through the links I’ve provided — which just happen to be great deals!
I’ve thought about doing this for awhile because if there’s one type of question I get more than any other, it’s “What ____ (TV/MP3 player/camera/monitor/laptop/etc) should I buy?” I keep up on most of this stuff, so allow me to point out my favorites for this season. My criteria is really just one thing: what gets you the most for your money?
I’m going to hit the big categories first and probably come back later to make more obscure picks. Do you want a recommendation? Hit up the comments!
JUMP TO MY PICKS FOR THE BEST…
- HDTV
- Portable GPS
- Laptop
- Portable music player
- Point-and-shoot camera
- Consumer DSLR
- Blu-Ray player
- Overall gadget under $100
Best HDTV
Samsung LN46A550 46 Inch 1080p LCD HDTV
Few companies make televisions that converge in quality, beauty, and price like Samsung does. I’ve got one of last year’s models and I love it. They just usually seem to hit the sweet spot between those attributes. For a little over $1200 (including Amazon’s excellent white-glove delivery service; trust me, you don’t want Bob, the guy who helped move your couch, moving your new HDTV), you can pick up the LN46A550 — which I know just rolls right off the tongue — and you get a beautiful picture, plenty of inputs, an elegant frame, and a very palatable 46 inches of HD goodness. There’s smaller and larger versions of this, of course, but 46 inches plenty big for most family rooms and offers the best bang for the buck right now.
Bargain hunter runner-up: If you’re looking to keep it under $1k, the Sharp Aquos LC42D64U 42 Inch 1080p LCD HDTV would be my choice. If you’re all about style and don’t care how much money you waste, buy one of the Sony TVs.
Best portable GPS
Garmin nĂ¼vi 360 3.5 Inch Portable GPS Navigator
You can pretty much spend as much as you want to on GPS devices, but there’s so many good ones for under $200 these days. One key feature is text-to-speech, where it reads the road names to you. This ~$150 Garmin wins out over the slightly cheaper competitors in this price range because most of them will only say “In 500 feet, turn left” whereas the Garmin will say “In 500 feet, turn left on Jackson Road.” I find that to be very valuable. It comes with both dashboard and windshield mounts, and car and wall chargers. Garmin also won a GPS comparison test for having the most efficient routing (an article which I can’t find right now, but I read it before I bought my GPS earlier this year).
Bargain hunter runner-up: It’s hard to recommend any devices cheaper than this because I don’t think any of them have text-to-speech, but if you really don’t think you’ll care about that feature you can pick up the TomTom ONE 125 3.5 Inch Portable GPS Navigator for $120 (or $99 sometimes on sale).
NOTE: Changed recommendation from the 350 to the 360 since the 350 was discontinued. The 360 is nearly identical, it just adds Bluetooth.
Best laptop
Apple MacBook
Yes, obviously I’m an Apple lover, and yes, there’s still a bit of an “Apple tax,” but the new MacBooks are hard to ignore. It’s got an extremely solid aluminum chassis, is really thin, has a gorgeous screen, a trick trackpad, and a glut of great creative software already installed when it comes out of the box. Not to mention being able to run both OS X and Windows at the same time with something like VMware Fusion — it’s like having two machines in one. And few people’s lives wouldn’t be improved by running Mac OS X instead of Windows.
Bargain hunter runner-up: If you want a Mac laptop but $1300 is a little steep, check out Apple’s refurb store. You can sometimes find previous-gen (still plenty fast) MacBooks in there for $899 or even $799. These are 100% perfect machines that carry a full Apple warranty — I’ve bought a few from there myself and they’ve been great. If you have absolutely no interest in a Mac, then after you get your head checked (I kid, I kid!) I would recommend the Dell Inspiron 1420 that starts at $599. I’ve found those to be pretty solid machines, and with a coupon they can get even cheaper.
Portable music player
Apple iPhone/iPod touch
OK, no shock here…my iPhone is without a doubt the best MP3 player I’ve ever used. If you don’t want to switch to AT&T or just don’t want to pay the monthly fees, the iPod touch 8GB for $215 will get you all the same iPod and gaming goodness. Yes, gaming…some of the stuff in the app store is fantastic. If 8GB is a little too paltry, step it up to the 16 GB for $285. Those prices are for the second-gen Touch; if you don’t mind the slightly thicker (but still really thin) form factor of the first-gen, you can get 16 GB for just $220.
Bargain hunter runner-up: Grab a super-slim 8 GB iPod nano for just $135.
Best point-and-shoot camera
Canon PowerShot SD770IS
Talk about a saturated market…frankly, it’s hard to go really wrong these days when you buy a point-and-shoot camera, but I’d go with the Canon 770IS because for just $160 it has image stabilization, great image quality, face recognition, and a good screen.
Big spender runner-up: The Canon SD880IS is even better, with more zoom range and a larger LCD. However, it’s nearly $100 more. Worth it? Up to you.
Consumer DSLR camera
Nikon D90
The consumer DSLR market is getting crowded (I’m focusing on the low end of the DSLR market because I doubt pros ask for their gear for Christmas — or care what I say
), but one recent standout is the Nikon D90. This sits at the top of their consumer line, and for under $1200 you get quite a lot. 12.3 MP, a self-cleaning sensor, a gorgeous on-camera LCD, live view, a pretty darn good 18-105mm stabilized kit lens, the first DSLR with movie mode (and 720p HD at that — although you do have to focus manually), 11-area autofocus, an HDMI port for displaying your shots/movies on TVs, some really good dynamic lighting enhancements, and of course what Nikons are well known for — great performance in low light. If you (or a loved one) are a budding photographer and you’ve got the coin, this is a great kit for the money.
Bargain hunter runner-up: Both Nikon and Canon offer great low-price DSLRs at the bottom of the consumer line in the Nikon D40 (what I own) and the Canon Rebel XS. The Canon is about $465 and the Nikon can be had for just $410!
Blu-Ray player
None
Ah-ha! Gotcha! OK, in my opinion it’s still too early for most people to get a Blu-Ray player. Prices are still falling fast, there’s too few models, and too many of the ones that are available have their own “gotchas.” But if you’re really dying to get some of that Blu goodness right now, I’d recommend the Samsung BD-P1500. It’s only about $200, performs pretty well, and is getting in on the Netflix streaming movie action just like the pricier LG Blu-Ray players and the Xbox 360. Personally, though, I would still wait. I think middle/late next year will be the point to get in on Blu-Ray.
Best overall gadget under $100
Logitech Harmony 550 Universal Remote
Few gadgets have simplified our home as much as the Harmony 550. Logitech revolutionized the concept of universal remotes with the Harmony line — they don’t just control multiple devices, they set up your intended activity with a single button press. This used to be the realm only of very expensive custom home theater installations. Now, it can be yours for $68. Anyone who does more than just watch TV with their TV can benefit from one of these. They’re especially handy for the non-technical ones…my wife doesn’t have to remember to set the TV to HDMI input 2, the receiver to Digital 1, power on the Xbox, and set the HDMI switcher box to input 2 to watch a movie — she just presses “Watch DVD” on the remote. I even have it controlling the lights in my family room via an X10 adapter!
See? Way under $100. I like the 550’s layout a lot, but if you prefer the peanut shape there’s the Harmony 670 for $75. There’s ones with color screens for more $$, but they’re not worth it.
That’s it for now. Let me know if there’s other categories I should hit!









Shane December 6th, 2008 at 12:27 am
Thanks to stumbling across your blog a few weeks back, you had pretty well convinced me I needed the Harmony 550 for my home theater setup, or will be home theater. So I went ahead and picked one up from pcrichard.com for $50shipped. Once setup, which was fairly easy, my system is very easily controlled with one remote. Well worth the money for sure, and it will make it even easier when I get the HDTV and receiver in a few months.
As a side note if others want to order from pcrichard their $50 price is apparently only available on the weekends.
martin December 12th, 2008 at 9:59 am
Your blog is very interesting. I just went through your list of bestgadgets and I must say you are spot on. I picked up a 550 harmony remote from. Amazon a few months back I have never been more satisfied. Its easy to use and there customer support is absolutely amazing.
They spent approximatly four hours on the phone with me helping me to set up my. Samsung hdtv and blue ray player to my reciever. They wouldn’t let up until they got all figured out. I would recommend them any day.Anyway just want to say keep up the good work.
Matthew December 12th, 2008 at 11:30 pm
Martin, thanks! I’m glad you like the blog, and it’s good to know I made some good choices with the gadget list. Enjoy your Harmony!
tarocchi December 14th, 2008 at 2:22 am
many compliments for your usefull and interesting article…i fiund it to be of great interest for me. thanks
Steve Cohen January 9th, 2009 at 5:42 pm
We got a new home entertainment center for Christmas, and the wife is going nuts without a universal remote. This one looks pretty good to me!